Hepatitis B is turned into liver cirrhosis Doubt that takes the medicine lawsuit of the hospital to make for eight years by mistake

Hepatitis B is turned into liver cirrhosis Doubt that takes the medicine lawsuit of the hospital to make for eight years by mistake
It is reported (reporter Liu YiMing) The dispute of doctors and patients who took place eight years ago, the woman patient is called the diagnosis of the hospital and prescribed medicine and went wrongs firmly, make her turn from ordinary hepatitis B patient into liver cirrhosis, two grades of courts in back Foshan sentence it to lose a lawsuit. Yesterday, the case it is reviewed that the intermediate court opened a court session in Foshan. The patient narrates: Take the intersection of hospital and medicine, cause critically ill will it be December 2 1999 such as life by mistake, 50 year old at that time, have Ms Zhang, hepatitis B of medical history go to a doctor at the place where Shuande had held one hospital very once, diagnosed as " Primary blood platelet reducing purpura " With " chronic hepatitis B " ,Need hospital treatment, and used a large amount of " prednisone " Hormone. In hospital after the two day, Ms Zhang present, suffer from diarrhoea, appear stomachache, the intersection of liver and the intersection of belly and symptom such as being uncomfortable again. She suspects that takes hormone " Prednisone " The bad reaction caused, but according to the doctor's opinion, she has to continue taking medicine. On January 6, 2000, Ms Zhang's liver function worsened seriously, transferred to Shuande hospital next day. Ms Zhang says, on February 16 of the same year, Shuande hospital did the belly CT scanning for her, the conclusion was that " the liver changed. Consider nodular liver cirrhosis, slight fat change the sex " The doctor in charge tells she, original " primary blood platelet reducing purpura " Diagnose that wrong. In the last ten days of March, Shuande hospital holds a consultation to Ms Zhang, a lemology professor tells Ms Zhang, the reason why her liver is damaged within short time seriously, should result from taking a large amount of hormone. Ms Zhang also claims, she went to three institutes in Guangzhou Zhongshan to go to a doctor again later, the doctor in charge thought too her liver cirrhosis was because of taking " prednisone " Cause. The hospital also found her to infect rare bead fungus septicaemia and latent coccus meningitis, these two kinds of diseases " Prednisone " May become the inducement. At the end of March of 2004, because Ms Zhang's condition worsened, bilirubin rose to more than 600, separated serious gallbladder enzyme, critically ill, the doctors of three institutes of Zhongshan tell its relative, such as not making liver transfer operation after having a meeting, must undoubtedly die within a few days. Fortunately, until March 31 contact, come liver support body, Ms Zhang finish behind the operation breaking away from life dangering finally too. The hospital defends oneself: It totally accords with and lets the strange hospital debate and claim, it totally accords with the routine of making a diagnosis that they attend to the making a diagnosis of Ms Zhang conventionally to make a diagnosis and attend to. Ms Zhang has already suffered from hepatitis B for many years before this, liver cirrhosis is the result that chronic hepatitis B develops for a long time. Let the strange hospital still think latent coccus meningitis,etc. and disease that she suffers from are caused by many kinds of factors, its mechanism is complicated, and Ms Zhang is leaving hospital without presenting symptom infected with of generating heat etc. until the last more than three months, so the making a diagnosis and giving treatment of these diseases and hospitals does not have direct relation. Yesterday, let attorney lawyer Cheng of the strange hospital claim in the court, though the other hospitals were different from judgement that they make, but the majority is only judged by individual whom the specific doctor of the hospital at the same level makes, but the judgement which three institutes of Zhongshan make, it is after one year and 9 months ill to Ms Zhang, anything has happened on earth during this time, no one is clear, the diagnosis of the strange hospital is wrong improper that whereby thought only to let. Lawyer Cheng also says, " prednisone " Treat the first-selected medicine that the blood platelet reduced, use medicine for time for about one month rationally, the consumption of the hospital is suitable, will not cause the infection. Court's trial focus: Original medical treatment determines that there is not expert's conclusion book that a key evidence among them is this case in this case of expert's signature. In 2001 the technological evaluation committee of the malpractice of Shuande determined that drew the conclusion to think, (Ms Zhang) Liver cirrhosis is resulted from condition development of chronic hepatitis B, with using hormone not to have direct relation. " Ms Zhang thinks, lets the strange hospital diagnose it is primary that its blood platelet reduces disease, and other hospital diagnose blood platelet their it reduces diseases to be to continue person who take place, so she ask, appraise again. Ms Zhang's husband Mr. Fang still points out, according to the legal provision, any testimonial should have signatures which appraises personnel, and this testimonial has an official seal only, so is illegal. Lawyer Cheng claims firmly in the court, qualification results of the expert's conclusion book are all true and valid. Is it a legal problem to have no expert to sign for appraising, he says, the relevant law had not stipulated that there should experts that signed at that time, so though only stamp the official seal, conform with legal provision. This newspaper will continue following up on this case. The retrospect of case: Lose a lawsuit bitter to wait, examine " I spend more thanth hospitalization cost in the past few years again six year twice, must repel and resist infection by expensive resisting every day now medicine maintains the life. " Ms Zhang says. In August of 2001, Ms Zhang was sued to the municipal court of Shuande, demanded to let the strange hospital compensate for about 1,700,000 yuan. The court tries thinking, the applicable fault principle of the dispute of compensation for damage of the malpractice, the evidence that Ms Zhang cites can't prove the hospital uses " Prednisone " Wrong, can't prove the hospital has neglecting one's duty or behavior of the technological fault, her claims should be rejected. In January of 2002, Ms Zhang appealed to the intermediate court of Foshan. In May, the intermediate court of Foshan trusted the technological evaluation committee of the malpractice of Guangdong Province to appraise again according to the request of her. In August of the same year, this committee provided the conclusion, thought unanimously that did not form the malpractice. At the end of September, the intermediate court of Foshan adopts this testimonial of the letter, makes final judgement, reject the appeal, uphold decision. Whether on February 10, 2004, the intermediate court of Foshan reviewed hearing. Ms Zhang's husband Mr. Fang has submitted seven new evidences altogether to judge at the hearing, in that relevant experts such as the medical university of Zhongshan, Guangzhou air hospital are about taking " Prednisone " There is conclusion increasing the condition consequence of liver cirrhosis directly, there are four medical works, so as to prove the wife's liver cirrhosis is the clothes because of following the doctor's advice " Prednisone " Due to. In March of this year, province Supreme Court made a decision, the decision sends back and rehears this case.

|